You Need Three Butterflies to Cause a Hurricane


  • Gianluca Piero Maria Virgilio



Flash Crash, abnormal market events, volatility, liquidity, stop-loss orders


The aim of this study is verifying the impact of high volatility, scarce liquidity and stop-loss orders on abnormal events like the May 6, 2010 Flash Crash. The paper assumes those three factors to be the main drivers, proposes a mathematical model based upon them and analyses audit trail data to verify whether those factors actually were at the origin of that event. It uses the concept of 'run', an uninterrupted sequence of trades all occurring in the same direction and compares volatility, liquidity and occurrence of stop-loss orders over the analysis period. The results found provide suggestive evidence that a combination of the three factors contributed to the crash. Each of them, taken individually, does not usually lead to extreme behaviours. Even two factors together may not disturb the orderly functioning of the markets but the combination of volatility, scarce liquidity and stop-loss orders may lead to a crisis.

JEL Codes - G12


Anderson, N., Webber, L., Noss, J., Beale, D., and Crowley-Reidy, L., 2015. The resilience of financial market liquidity. Financial Stability paper, 34(October).

Bullock, S., 2011. Prospects for large scale financial systems simulation. The Future of Computer Trading in Financial Markets. Foresight Driver Review – DR 14.

Cespa, G., and Foucault, T., 2014. Illiquidity Contagion and Liquidity Crashes. The Review of Financial Studies, 27(6), 1615–1660.

CFTC-SEC Advisory Committee on Emerging Regulatory Issues, 2010a. Findings Regarding the Market Events of May 6, 2010.

CFTC-SEC Advisory Committee on Emerging Regulatory Issues, 2010b. Preliminary Findings Regarding the Market Events of May 6, 2010.

Cliff, D., 2011. Regulatory scrutiny of algorithmic trading systems: an assessment of the feasibility and potential economic impact. Government Office for Science, EIA16.

Danielsson, J., and Zer, I., 2012. Systemic risk arising from computer based trading and connections to the empirical literature on systemic risk. Government Office for Science, DR29.

Durden, T., 2012. Was the SEC "Explanation" Of the Flash Crash Maliciously Fabricated or Completely Flawed Out Of Plain Incompetence? ZeroHedge.

Foresight - Government Office for Science, 2012. Future of computer trading in financial markets: final report.

Gleick, J., 2008. Chaos - Making a New Science. New York: Penguin Books.

Goldstein, I., Li, Y., and Yang, L., 2013. Speculation and Hedging in Segmented Markets. The Review of Financial Studies, 27(3), 881-922.

Granger, C., 1969. Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-spectral Methods. Econometrica, 37(3), 424-438.

Kirilenko, A., Kyle, A., Samadi, M., and Tuzun, T., 2017. The Flash Crash: The Impact of High Frequency Trading on an Electronic Market. The Journal of Finance, 72(3), 967-998.

Madhavan, A., 2012. Exchange Traded Funds, Market Structure and the Flash Crash. Financial Analysts Journal, 68(4), 20-35.

Menkveld, A., and Yueshen, B., 2019. The Flash Crash: A Cautionary Tale About Highly Fragmented Markets. Management Science, 65(10), 4470-4488.

Nanex, 2010a. Analysis of the "Flash Crash" - Intro Empirical Analysis. from

Nanex, 2010b. Analysis of the "Flash Crash" - Part 1 Empirical Analysis. from

Schapiro, M., 2010. Testimony Concerning the Severe Market Disruption on May 6, 2010. Before the Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance and Government Sponsored Enterprises of the United States House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services.

Sornette, D., and von der Becke, S., 2011. Crashes and High Frequency Trading. Government Office for Science, DR7.

Zervoudakis, F., Lawrence, D., Gontikas, G., and Al Merey, M., 2012. Perspectives on High-Frequency Trading. University College London White paper.




How to Cite

Virgilio, G. P. M. (2020). You Need Three Butterflies to Cause a Hurricane. Scientific Annals of Economics and Business, 67(1), 139–155.